When one of the Girls Next Door battles a High School Musical hottie in a celebrity fashion clash, you know it’s going to get hideous.

Or hot.

You be the judge. Here’s Ashley Tisdale, attending L.A.’s American Music Awards, and Bridget Marquardt, hitting up the Espy awards in L.A., both wearing the same sexy, glittered, $1,349 platinum frock from Mandalay.

Ashley Tisdale FashionBridget Marquardt

Who wore it better: Ashley Tisdale or Bridget Marquardt?

Via [thehollywoodgossip]